May 21, 2012
Weather

Fair

58°
Feels Like: 58 °
More Weather
Conditions at Wausau Downtown Airport, WI
Save Email Print Bookmark and Share
A A
Reporter: Liz Hayes Email

Dog Falls Through Ice, Owners Say Sheriff Should Have Sent Deputy

A Portage County family is grieving the loss of a family pet, who drowned in Lake Du Bay Friday after falling through thin ice.

Though Susan Suthers called 911, she and her husband Corey say she didn't get the help she needed.

"I didn't know what else to do, my dog went out on the ice because these snow geese were out here and he fell through and it's thick enough that I can't, he can't get up," Suthers told dispatchers in a recorded 911 call. "He fell through and I don't know how to get him out."

Suthers were home alone when she looked out the picture window and saw her newly adopted dog, Miles, struggling to get out of the ice-covered lake.

After calling her husband, who was several miles away, she called 911.

"I needed help. I didn't know what else to do. I thought I was, it was the right thing to do," she said.

But the Portage County Sheriff's Department doesn't do animal rescues, unless an animal is posing a danger to people.

Suthers were instructed to call back on the non-emergency line and was put in touch with the Humane Society of Portage County, located in Plover and about a 20 minute drive. The humane society employee said she'd be over as soon as possible.

Meanwhile, Miles was barely holding on.

"I was trying to go out to save my baby but there was nothing I could do. There was nobody here to back me up, to help me," Suthers said.

Her neighbors weren't home, and she couldn't get her family's kayak down from the garage by herself. She got into the water, trying to break the ice to no avail.

By the time the humane employee and her husband arrived, Miles had gone under.

"It's disappointing when you hear one community that'll go out and save an animal, and another community that says no, we don't save animal," said Corey Suthers.

Portage County Sheriff' John Charewicz says he himself is a dog lover and says it's unfortunate Miles drowned, but the county has limited resources and they can't respond to animal calls.

"We're not set up to handle that," he said.

But the Suthers say, if only a deputy or another emergency worker would have been sent right away, or if dispatchers would have put a call out to surrounding areas, maybe Miles could have been rescued.

"It's their job to come out and help," Corey Suthers said.

NewsChannel 7 checked with other sheriff's departments on animal rescue. Both Marathon and Wood counties said they do respond to animal rescue calls, but they wouldn't put a deputy in danger.


Comments (74)

By posting this comment I have read and agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy:
You must agree to the Terms of Service to continue.

Read Comments

All comments must adhere to the WSAW.com discussion rules.

  • by Eric Renfert Location: Stevens Point on Dec 10, 2011 at 08:49 PM
    I don't know about you guys, but I would have gladly stripped down and gone straight in for her. Obviously the owner isn't an 18 year old lifeguard, and I understand that she would have been in danger if she went in alone. I don't think a deputy going in on the end of a rope, or even helping her get down her kayak, which she asked them to do, would have been putting a human life in danger, if they got in, grabbed the dog, got out, and went inside, they would have been fine. Especially with a wetsuit.
  • by Anonymous Location: WI on Dec 9, 2011 at 08:56 AM
    Are all you inconsiderate people ignoring what the EMT and other rescue service people are saying? They are trained for this stuff and it's what they do, CLEARLY it SHOULD have been done! They said it themselves!
  • by Anonymous Location: WI on Dec 9, 2011 at 08:56 AM
    Are all you inconsiderate people ignoring what the EMT and other rescue service people are saying? They are trained for this stuff and it's what they do, CLEARLY it SHOULD have been done! They said it themselves!
  • by Me Location: Everywhere on Dec 8, 2011 at 11:15 PM
    Someone should at least responded to the call. Tie a rope to me and help me if I get in trouble, my choice . Show up and help me get my kayak down so I can try to do the right thing. To not respond at all should be a criminal offense. The call was made, at least do the minimum moral obligation. all those involved should be fired. At least have the b@lls to show up and say, "sorry, nothing I can do. We just don't have the finances to help you, even though that is our job. have a nice day"
  • by Gayle on Dec 8, 2011 at 09:54 PM
    If a pet owner doesn't want to be judged, they might consider next time not putting the story in the news. Both the dog and the owner had a stake in this and the dog lost. Obviously the owner did not want to put her life on the line, why put a public worker's? It is no more their job than it is the owners.
  • by Jane on Dec 8, 2011 at 04:26 PM
    Sounds like some can't differentiate between animal and human being!
    • reply
      by Anonymous on Dec 10, 2011 at 09:21 AM in reply to Jane
      And which would you be? Who has the lack of compassion - animals or humans??
  • by Anonymous on Dec 8, 2011 at 02:07 PM
    It is a sad situation, but we absolutely can't expect public employees to risk their lives for a pet or any other animal. If they're equipt for it fine, but what can we expect them to do if they don't have the specialized equipment available? I doubt most police or Sheriff's are equipt for such a rescue. In my area the fire departments have ice rescue equipment, but do we really expect the volunteer firefighters to leave their jobs for an animal rescue? Would owners really cough up between $500 - $1000 to reimburse the departments to respond? I really am sorry for the dogs owner, but you expect too much.
  • by Anonymous on Dec 8, 2011 at 09:17 AM
    HONESTLY PEOPLE!?!?! someones pet fell through the ice and drowned. She watched it. She was heart broken. It would be just like watching a human drowned. WHAT DO YOU DO?! run out on the ice and have a dog AND a human drowned. Then you people would probably comment on how idiotic she is for running out. You can never win anyones sympathy i guess. She called for help. JUST like if someone has a heart attack, you call 911..FOR HELP! A pet is someones world too. whether you adopted it at 10 years old, Or you were with it since birth. Now i know people in this community can be cruel but really?! Give these people some simpathy. Yes we cant all control our animals. But when a dog gets hit by a car are you just going to stand there and say, "Well, i should have trained it better" or when it gets bitten by another animal, are you going to say "Guess i should have trained it to run away". You people act like its a fly that fell through. ITS A DOG. I hope if ANY of you unsympathetic people have an animal that it is THEE MOST PERFECT ANIMAL known to man. And when that animal passes away. I hope to GOD you dont cry. Cause that is just the type of people you are being right now. Never in a million years did i Think the people of Portage county could be THIS mean. it is just unreal.
    • reply
      by Gloria on Dec 8, 2011 at 04:31 PM in reply to
      Please contact your counselor, you obviously need to GET A GRIP!!!
      • reply
        by Susan on Dec 9, 2011 at 07:49 AM in reply to Gloria
        I am a counselor, and quite frankly, think you are the one who needs the help. People that are so cold and heartless that they can't even connect with the love of an animal are the ones with the issues. I am appalled at the lack of feeling, and the hatred that is pouring out of the people in this area. It is shameful. These people are suffering - this dog suffered horribly. This society is in trouble.
  • by Anonymous on Dec 8, 2011 at 08:59 AM
    (Mam whose husband is a firefighter) In all honesty, Firefighers/ Paramedics are TRAINED to go out on thin ice and help ANYONE who has fallen through the ice. Whether it is the beginning, middle, or end of winter. If a human being has fell through the ice that is THEIR job to save them and be cautious while doing (like they were trained). You wouldnt let a human being drowned because it is unsafe for the Officer, Paramedic, Firefighter. Why would you let a helpless animal?! So in reality, it should not matter if it was a human being or an animal. Help is help. And a pet is someones life too. Very disrespectful if you ask me. Other than that obnoxious comment, Yes, i think Portage county should have sent someone out to rescue Miles. Just rediculous. I am SO unbelievably sorry for your loss :(
  • by mal on Dec 8, 2011 at 12:08 AM
    Remember everyone, anger is one of the five stages of grief. We are only human. The things we say and the decisions we make on a normal day differ greatly from those in times of distress. An emergency service worker should always put their personal safety first. It would have been a greater tragedy to lose a human life as well. That said, be kind with your words. Let the owners be human and deal with their loss.

Current Conditions

Weather

Fair

54°
Feels Like: 51 °
More Weather
Conditions at Antigo - Lang Automatic Weather Observing / Report, WI
Weather

Fair

58°
Feels Like: 58 °
More Weather
Conditions at Wausau Downtown Airport, WI
Weather

Fair

55°
Feels Like: 52 °
More Weather
Conditions at Clintonville Municipal Airport, WI
Weather

Fair

55°
Feels Like: 51 °
More Weather
Conditions at Baraboo Wisconsin Dells Airport, WI
Weather

Fair

54°
Feels Like: 53 °
More Weather
Conditions at Eagle River Union Airport, WI
Weather

Fair

58°
Feels Like: 55 °
More Weather
Conditions at Marshfield Municipal Airport, WI
Weather

Fair

55°
Feels Like: 53 °
More Weather
Conditions at Medford, Taylor County Airport, WI
Weather

Fair

55°
Feels Like: 53 °
More Weather
Conditions at Medford, Taylor County Airport, WI
Weather

Fair

55°
Feels Like: 52 °
More Weather
Conditions at Minocqua / Woodruff, WI
Weather

Clear

55°
Feels Like: 52 °
More Weather
Conditions at Mosinee / Central Wisconsin, WI
Weather

Fair with Haze

57°
Feels Like: 56 °
More Weather
Conditions at Phillips / Price County, WI
Weather

Fair

55°
Feels Like: 53 °
More Weather
Conditions at Rhinelander-Oneida County Airport, WI
Weather

Fair

59°
Feels Like: 58 °
More Weather
Conditions at Shawano Municipal Airport, WI
Weather

Fair

56°
Feels Like: 54 °
More Weather
Conditions at Stevens Point Municipal Airport, WI
Weather

Fair

54°
Feels Like: 52 °
More Weather
Conditions at Tomahawk Regional Airport, WI
Weather

Fair

59°
Feels Like: 57 °
More Weather
Conditions at Wisconsin Rapids, Alexander Field So. Wood County, WI
Weather

Fair

59°
Feels Like: 57 °
More Weather
Conditions at Volk / Camp Douglas, WI
Weather

Fair

59°
Feels Like: 56 °
More Weather
Conditions at Waupaca Municipal Airport, WI
Weather

Fair

60°
Feels Like: 58 °
More Weather
Conditions at Wautoma Municipal Airport, WI

My Local TITAN - Click Radar for More Maps

NEW: Launch Interactive Weather Map

Stock indexes

  • .DJI
  • 12408.43
  • +39.05
  • 0.32%
  • .INX
  • 1298.93
  • +3.71
  • 0.29%
  • .IXIC
  • 2779.50
  • +0.71
  • 0.03%
  • NYA
  • 8151.97
  • +15.73
  • 0.19%
Enter Ticker Symbol to get quote:
Quotes updated every 15 minutes