School District Receives Hundreds of Emails After Pulling Student Gay Adoption Piece
Save Email Print
Bookmark and Share
Updated: 4:36 PM Jan 31, 2012
School District Receives Hundreds of Emails After Pulling Student Gay Adoption Piece
Now an attorney with the Liberty Counsel, a non-profit law firm specializing in first amendment rights, is representing Wegner. Harry Mihet says Wegner's first amendment rights have been outrageously violated.
Posted: 4:36 PM Jan 31, 2012
Reporter: Liz Hayes
Email Address: lhayes@wsaw.com

Gay Adoption Article Causes Controversy
Font Size:

Earlier this month Brandon Wegner, 15, a Shawano Community High School sophomore, wrote an editorial in the student newspaper opposing gay adoption. Another student, Maddie Marquardt, wrote an opinion piece right next to Wegners, arguing we can't judge whether someone is a suitable parent simply by their sexual orientation.

But after running in the student newspaper, which appeared as an insert in the Shawano Leader, the opinion pieces have been removed from remaining copies.

Now an attorney with the Liberty Counsel, a non-profit law firm specializing in first amendment rights, is representing Wegner. Harry Mihet says Wegner's first amendment rights have been outrageously violated.

Mihet says Wegner was given the topic of gay adoption. In his opinion piece he quotes the bible and says, "In a Christian society allowing homosexual couples to adopt is an abomination."

After the piece ran, the Shawano School District decided to remove it from the school newspaper.

Mihet says whether you agree with gay adoption or not is irrelevant.

"He did nothing more than to express his opinion on a particular topic, an opinion in which with some are free to agree and some to disagree but an opinion which is absolutely protected with the first amendment of the Constitution" Mihet said.

Mihet alleges the school district superintendent, Todd Carlson, pulled Wegner out of class and made him feel ashamed for his piece.

"The superintendent told him that he had violated the school's bullying policy," Mihet said. "The superintendent also told him he was ignorant and all kinds of demeaning names."

Now Liberty Counsel is demanding the school district give Wegner a sincere apology. They also want the district to make it clear to students and the community that student journalists have the first amendment right to express their opinions.

The firm is threatening litigation against the Shawano School District if they don't comply.

Carlson sent a statement saying the situation has escalated to the point where school district staff have been threatened.

He also says he did not call Wegner any names, and that Wegner was the one who initiated a conversation with him.

Carlson says the section of the student newspaper including both pro and con viewpoints was pulled from extra copies of the newspaper at school, and no further action was taken.

But Mihet says his client was told he can no longer write for the student paper, and that's bad news for all student journalists.

"A student journalist has no choice but to fear punishment approaching any topic because they could end up just the same way that Brandon has ended up," Mihet said.

On January 31, a school district representative told NewsChannel 7 they've received hundreds of e-mails and telephone calls in support and opposition of the action.


Latest Comments

Posted by: anon on Feb 21, 2012 at 10:45 AM

what unions? WI doesn't have teacher unions anymore.
Posted by: Scythe on Feb 2, 2012 at 02:10 PM

Don’t let the LGBT agenda a small percentage of public opinion influence. The argument of being born gay has been scientifically proven that there is no gay gene. This comes to no surprise to Christians who have always said that God did not create sin and instead Satan wants everyone to believe the lie! The truth is slow moving giving reason as to why the LGBT is eager to push gay marriage before it is widely known that being gay is a choice and not a virtue.
Posted by: Casey Location: Wisconsin on Feb 2, 2012 at 04:40 AM

I was wondering why the same people who can condemn Brandon for “hate speech” can say that this child is a brat or should be slapped? It that not a form of hate speech in itself…not to mention promoting child abuse.
My Local TITAN - Click Radar for More Maps
NEW: Launch Interactive Weather Map
Stock Indexes
  • .DJI
  • 12938.67
  • -27.02
  • -0.21%
  • .INX
  • 1357.66
  • -4.55
  • -0.33%
  • NYA
  • 8094.39
  • -21.04
  • -0.26%
Enter Ticker Symbal to get quote:
Quotes updated every 15 minutes
  • FL
  • 28.36
  • SF
  • 38.23
  • VZ
  • 38.21
  • WY
  • 20.71