New Guidelines For Breast Cancer Detection Surprising
Save Email Print
Updated: 12:02 AM Nov 18, 2009
New Guidelines For Breast Cancer Detection Surprising
New guidelines from a government task force say women should start getting mammograms at age 50, not 40 as recommended before. They should also have them every other year rather than annually. And self-breast exams may not be effective.
Posted: 3:55 PM Nov 17, 2009
Reporter: Liz Hayes
Email Address: lhayes@wsaw.com

New Guidelines For Breast Cancer Detection Turn Women's Health Upside Down
New Guidelines For Breast Cancer Detection Surprising
Font Size:

The guidelines from a government task force say women should start getting mammograms at age 50, not 40 as recommended before.

The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force also suggests women be screened every two years, rather than annually.

Women and those who work in women's health have a lot more to think about with these stunning new guidelines.

The group of scientists and doctors involved in this study found yearly mammograms for younger women may do more harm than good.

For women between 40 and 50, too many times there are false positives -- meaning something shows up in the screening but turns out to be nothing.

That leads to anxiety, stress, and unnecessary biopsies and tests.

"And did that help that person when there wasn't anything wrong in the first place?" asks Julie Luks, M.D., medical director of Aspirus Women's Health.

The task force also recommends doctors don't tell patients to examine their breasts on a regular basis.

"Most of the time its not that affective, according to this paper, and it too leads to the kind of harm that is being described...many extra tests, many extra biopsies, much anxiety," says Dr. Luks.

She says the vast majority of findings from self-breast exams do not find an underlying cancer.

But early detection was key to saving Bobette Helgeson's life.

She found a golf ball sized lump in her breast six years ago, but at first thought nothing of it.

"If I could just get one woman to start doing her self breast exam it would mean the world to me. If I can get the message out, it is imperative to do breast self exams," Helgeson said.

She's since cancer free.

But these guidelines were based on not finding cancer early, but if screening tests decrease mortality.

The study did find that mammograms reduce the risk of dying from breast cancer by 15 percent for women in their 40s and 50s.

And that's what many physicians will now take into consideration.

"It's a very big change, kind of a paradigm shift and something we need to consider," Dr. Luks said.

She also says to keep your scheduled mammogram for now.


Aspirus Health Beat 7 helps you make better health care decisions with news about the latest medical breakthroughs, research and technology. Tune in for information about exciting new care options you and your family can access right here in central Wisconsin through Aspirus doctors, services and the Wausau Hospital.

December 21, 2009
Bar-Code System Supports Patient Safety
Joni Hahn, RN
Health Beat : Bar-Code System Supports Patient Safety

December 28, 2009
Confusion Problems in Seniors
Paula Brabec, RN
Health Beat : Confusion Problems in Seniors

January 4, 2010
Team Helps Women With Abnormal Bleeding
Paul Kerns, M.D.

January 11, 2010
Innovations In Joint Replacement Surgery
Daniel Seybold, M.D. & Daniel Priebe, M.D.
Health Beat : Innovations in Joint Replacement Surgery

January 18, 2010
Personalized Cancer Care
Christopher Peterson, M.D.
Health Beat : Personalized Cancer Care

January 25, 2010
Pain Relief For Facial Shingles
Mazin Ellias, M.D.
Health Beat : Pain Relief for Facial Shingles

February 1, 2010
3-D Technology Advances Heart Diagnostics
Germain Larrain, M.D.
Health Beat : 3-D Technology Advances Heart Diagnostics

February 8, 2010
Transporting Critically Ill Newborns
Sue McDonald, RN & Jason Keffeler, RN.
Health Beat : Transporting Critically Ill Newborns

February 15, 2010
Wireless Pacemaker Technology
Mark Hoffmann, M.D.
Health Beat : Wireless Pacemaker Technology

February 22, 2010
Treatment Options for Disc Herniation
Todd Fairchild, M.D.

March 1, 2010
Infertility Testing and Artificial Insemination
Jennifer Mullen, Nurse Practitioner
Health Beat : Infertility Testing and Artificial Insemination

March 8, 2010
Injection Therapy for Low Back Pain
Luke Budleski, M.D.
Health Beat : Injection Therapy for Low Back Pain

March 15, 2010
Minimally Invasive Colon Surgery
Steve Weiland, M.D.
Health Beat : Minimally Invasive Colon Surgery

March 22, 2010
2009 HomeCare Elite Award for VNA Health
Jean Burgener

March 29, 2010
Blue Distinction Designation for Joint Replacement Center
Kathy Drengler & Kelly O'Heron

April 5, 2010
Essential Women Program Benefits Self, Community
Sheri Holmes, RNC

April 12, 2010
Recreational Therapy Benefits Seniors
Ashly Schmidt, MS

April 17, 2010
Aspirus Pediatric Outpatient Therapy Services
Jennifer Kowalski

April 24, 2010
Manage Your Health Information On-Line with MyAspirus
Hilary Scully, M.D.

May 1, 2010
Prenatal Care Essential for Healthy Baby
Kristin Rham, M.D.

May 8, 2010
Intimacy Issues a New Focus of Women's Health
Julie Luks, M.D.

May 15, 2010
Women's Health Expands the Nurse Navigator Role
Sheri Holmes, RNC

May 22, 2010
Social Workers Benefit Cancer Patients
Wendy Schulz, MSW

May 29, 2010
Minimally Invasive Mitral Valve Surgery
Ronald Miles, M.D.

June 5, 2010
Importance of Preventive Care for Adults
Larry Gordon, O.D.

June 12, 2010
Laparoscopic Bariatric Surgery
Steve Weiland, M.D.

June 17, 2010
Treatment for Insomnia
James Cygan, M.D.