Is the H1N1 Vaccine Safe? Experts Sound Off
Save Email Print
Updated: 6:58 PM Nov 6, 2009
Is the H1N1 Vaccine Safe? Experts Sound Off
Many of you have questions about the safety of the H1N1 vaccine. While the medical community overwhelmingly supports the vaccine as safe, some still say enough hasn't been done to ensure its safety.
Posted: 6:00 PM Nov 6, 2009
Reporter: Mikel Lauber
Email Address: mlauber@wsaw.com

Questions About H1N1 Vaccine Answered
Font Size:

Providing accurate information about vaccines is part of the mission statement for the National Vaccine Information Center, a non-profit organization founded in 1982.

Barbara Loe Fisher, the group's president, who we spoke with via Skype from her living room near Washington, D.C., says we simply don't know enough about the h1n1 vaccine. "We have an H1N1 vaccine that was tested for a couple of weeks on a couple of thousand people, that was not tested on the high risk groups for which its being targeted”, said Fisher. “So this database they have is not robust in terms of the people they’re saying should get it, and this is of concern to us "

And it seems more and more parents are concerned as well. Recent polls from the Associated Press have shown 38% of parents say they're unlikely to have their children vaccinated, and 72% say they're worried about side effects.

Fisher says her organization doesn't recommend against any vaccine, but with a rise in autistic and chronically ill children in recent years, she says parents need to research and decide for themselves. "I encourage everyone to get full information”, said Fisher. “Don’t just go to our website. Go to the CDC, the American Academy of Pediatrics website, go to all of the websites and get the information."

Meanwhile, the nation's big medical organizations are rallying behind the vaccine, overwhelmingly saying it’s as safe as the seasonal flu vaccine, and urging especially those at risk to be vaccinated.

Dr. Jeff Lamont, a pediatrician for Marshfield Clinic, says he encourages questions from patients, and especially parents. But he says when it comes to this and other vaccines, the big questions have been answered. "When the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention support giving the vaccine, when the American Academy of Pediatrics and Academy of Family Physicians both support giving the vaccine, when the public health department supports giving the vaccine, you have to ask what information and what source could these parents have that they feel trumps those”, said Lamont.

The medical community says there is no risk-free vaccine. But medical organizations say the risks are small and rare, while risks associated with the virus are significant. "The parents who choose not to vaccinate reduce that very small chance of a vaccine reaction to zero”, said Lamont. “But in exchange, they expose their child in a much greater and much more serious way to a very serious disease which has killed children"

Fisher agrees that H1N1 and other diseases children are vaccinated against are dangerous, but she says a better effort has to be put forth by our Government to ensure that safe means safe. "It all comes back to doing the good science”, Fisher says. “We don’t think enough good science has been done in the vaccine arena, and I think until its done, you’re going to continue to have people questioning"

Will you or your family be getting the H1N1 vaccine? Why, or why not? Post your comments below.


Latest Comments

Posted by: Sarah on Nov 9, 2009 at 02:27 PM

Nope. I'll take my chances. It's all government scare tactics. Look at the frenzy the media has caused. How many people have died from it? How many have died from the regular flu? Give me a break. You're all going to die from the crap they put in the vaccine.
[ Report Abuse ]
Posted by: Bonny Location: Vermont on Nov 9, 2009 at 12:20 PM

No, i do not believe this vaccine is safe. I prefer to let my body build immunities naturally. I'm not about to allow someone to inject me with God knows what simply because the country is in a panic over a flu virus.
[ Report Abuse ]
Posted by: Clint Location: Wausau on Nov 7, 2009 at 09:44 AM

This vaccine will protect against H1N1, but it also damages your DNA. It will weaken your immune system and make you much more susceptible to contract other major illnesses for the rest of your life.
[ Report Abuse ]

Aspirus Health Beat 7 helps you make better health care decisions with news about the latest medical breakthroughs, research and technology. Tune in for information about exciting new care options you and your family can access right here in central Wisconsin through Aspirus doctors, services and the Wausau Hospital.

August 3, 2009
New Radiation Therapy Shortens Breast Cancer
Darryl Barton, MD ARCC
Health Beat: New Radiation Therapy Shortens Breast Cancer

August 10, 2009
LIpasorber
German Lorrain, MD AHVI

August 17, 2009
Level 2 Trauma Center
Jenny Larson, MD AWH
Health Beat: Level II Trauma Center

August 24, 2009
Kohl's Safety Center
Michelle Armstrong, AWH

August 31, 2009
SaferTreatment for Barrett's Esophagus (HALO)
Christopher Young, MD GI
Health Beat: SaferTreatment for Barrett's Esophagus

September 7, 2009
2009 HealthGrades Women's Health Excellence Award
Sherri Holmes
Health Beat: 2009 HealthGrades Women's Health Excellence Award

September 14, 2009
Single Room Care Newborn ICU
Sue McDonald, RN
Health Beat: Single Room Care NICU

September 21, 2009
New Lumbar Fusion Surgery
Dr. Beaumont and Dr. Brunch
Health Beat : New Lumbar Fusion Surgery

September 28, 2009
Nurse Navigator Assists Women
Chris Hanke, RN
Health Beat: Nurse Navigator Assists Women

October 5, 2009
Hospice Services Expand to Rhinelander
Jean Bergener

October 12, 2009
Adolescent Scoliosis
Dr. John Hugus

October 19, 2009
XOFT for Gynecologic Cancer
Dr. Tod Speer

October 26, 2009
AHVI Program Expands to MHC
Dr. Luetmer and Kaaron Keene

November 2, 2009
Heart Valve Surgery
Dr. Ronald Miles

November 9, 2009
Major Causes of Traumatic Injuries
Dr. Jenny Larson
Health Beat : Major Causes of Traumatic Injuries

November 16, 2009
Aspirus Safety Center Expands
Michelle Armstrong

November 23, 2009
Vitamin D Update
Dr. Hilary Bingol

November 30, 2009
New Cosmetic Procedures
Dr. Katharina Hahn

December 7, 2009
Improved Care for Seniors
Paula Brabec, RN

December 14, 2009
Beating Heart Surgery
Fernando Riveron, M.D.

December 21, 2009
Bar-Code System Supports Patient Safety
Joni Hahn, RN

December 28, 2009
Confusion Problems in Seniors
Paula Brabec, RN

January 4, 2010
Team Helps Women With Abnormal Bleeding
Paul Kerns, M.D.

January 11, 2010
Innovations In Joint Replacement Surgery
Daniel Seybold, M.D. & Daniel Priebe, M.D.

January 18, 2010
Personalized Cancer Care
Christopher Peterson, M.D.

January 25, 2010
Pain Relief For Facial Shingles
Mazin Ellias, M.D.

February 1, 2010
3-D Technology Advances Heart Diagnostics
Germain Larrain, M.D.

February 8, 2010
Transporting Critically Ill Newborns
Sue McDonald, RN & Jason Keffeler, RN

February 15, 2010
Wireless Pacemaker Technology
Mark Hoffmann, M.D.

February 22, 2010
Treatment Options for Disc Herniation
Todd Fairchild, M.D.

March 1, 2010
Infertility Testing and Artificial Insemination
Jennifer Mullen, Nurse Practitioner

March 8, 2010
Injection Therapy for Low Back Pain
Luke Budleski, M.D.

March 15, 2010
Minimally Invasive Colon Surgery
Steve Weiland, M.D.