First Warn On-Line: Breaking News and Weather Alerts to Your Desktop!
Fair
Temp: 74 F (23 C)
Humidity: 43
Heat Index: NA F
Home  ·   News  ·   DayBreak  ·   Weather  ·   Sports  ·   Entertainment  ·   Health  ·   Schools  ·   Politics  ·   Autos
Inside WSAW · Program Guide · Blog Center · Send it to 7 · Job Search · Community · Contests/Promotions · Creative Services · Sales · Recipes/Restaurants · Featured Links
Study Suggests Breast Self-Exams Do More Harm Than Good; Experts Disagree Save Email Print
Posted: 4:45 PM Jul 16, 2008
Last Updated: 5:49 PM Jul 17, 2008
Reporter: Liz Hayes
Email Address: lhayes@wsaw.com

A | A | A

A new report from an organization that evaluates medical research says there's no evidence that breast self-exams reduce breast cancer deaths.

It even suggests thay may do more harm than good...but some disagree.

Dr. Sally Mattingly says it's not news that breast self-exams may not change whether a woman who gets breast cancer lives or dies.

"First of all you need to be aware of your breasts and know if somethings changing and you can never know that unless you do your self-exams," said Dr. Mattingly.

But she says detecting a lump that may be malignant and getting yourself professionally screened will get you treatment.

"So maybe I can't tell you that if you found it yourself you'd have a better chance of living than dying of breast cancer but certainly you would get into the system and have things done for you."

The study also suggests only those with a family history should most definitely have monthly self-exams. But Dr. Mattingly says research shows only 10 to 15 percent of women who get breast cancer have a family history of the disease.

"The top two risk factors of getting breast cancer is being a woman and getting older, so it's very important for every woman to get out and get their screenings," said Erin Zastrow of the American Cancer Society.

Zastrow says before mammograms existed, self-exams were critical...but are still beneficial.

Having yearly mammograms and clinical exams are crucial, and so is being aware of changes in your breasts.

"Just know what it felt like the day you leave after having an exam with me or someone else, that's what is your baseline," said Dr. Mattingly.

She recommends paying attention to any changes you may experience for a few months after a clinical screening...even if you don't know what you're looking for.

She says if you find something unusual, contact a medical professional who can decide what to do next.

The Women's Breast Health Center recommends women begin practicing self and clinical breast exams in their late teens...and yearly mammograms starting at 40.

More Stories
Wisconsin Doctors Want to Keep $250 Million Malpractice Fund

Rural Eau Claire Man Suffers Fatal Hornet Sting

A New Program at Aspirus Wausau Hospital Hopes To Keep More Nurses In The Field

After 2 Deaths, Weather Service Warns of Currents

Weston, Marshfield Hospitals Named Among Best in Nation

Health Official: No Cause Yet for Outagamie County Jail Sickness

Hearings Set on Proposed Fee Increases in Wisconsin

Norovirus May Have Sickened Campers at Wis. Event

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: Gail Perry Location: St. Petersburg on Jul 17, 2008 at 09:04 PM
What an absurd "study." This is proof that statistics, in the wrong hands, are just plain dangerous. I found the lump in my breast. So did my mother, in 1958. She died, 31 years later, of something completely unrelated -- because she found that lump in time. My tumor was rapid growing. That's one reason to do them -- some tumors grow very fast. Another is just to be familiar with your breasts, because mammograms typically miss inflammatory breast cancer, a form that is often fatal unless caught very early. It does no harm. Finally, those chuckle-headed nincompoops who came out with this absurd position should re-run their statistics including only poor women who couldn't afford mammograms. Only 40% of women who should get mammograms. Let's not discourage them from doing self-exams as well!



Aspirus Health Beat 7 helps you make better health care decisions with news about the latest medical breakthroughs, research and technology. Tune in for information about exciting new care options you and your family can access right here in central Wisconsin through Aspirus doctors, services and the Wausau Hospital.


August 25, 2008
ENDOVASCULAR ANEURYSM COILING (December 17, 2007)
Christopher MacKay, MD

September 1, 2008
S.T.A.B.L.E. CARE FOR INFANTS
Sue McDonald, NICU Supervisor

September 8, 2008
HELICOPTER SERVICE FASTER, SAFER
Ralph Sliwicki, Lead Pilot

September 15, 2008
TREATING INFERTILITY
Randle Corfman, MD

September 22, 2008
FIRST IN WISCONSIN FOR NEW HEART REPAIR PROCEDURE
Fernando Riverton, MD

September 29, 2008
ROBOTIC SURGERY FOR HYSTERECTOMY
Anthony Bell, MD
Orestes Alvarez-Jacinto, MD

October 6, 2008
A SAFER TREATMENT FOR BARRETT'S ESOPHAGUS
Christopher Young, MD

October 13, 2008
TREATING BRAIN TUMORS
Andrew Beaumont, MD

October 20, 2008
WOMEN'S HEALTH MOBILE IMAGING UNIT
Linda Grilley, RN, MSN

October 27, 2008
HOSPICE PHYSICIAN MAKES HOUSE CALLS
Eileen Gavin, MD

November 3, 2008
TEAM APPROACH ENHANCES CARE FOR SPINAL PAIN
Margaret Anderson, MD

November 10, 2008
NEW TEST HELPS TREAT BOWEL INCONTINENCE IN WOMEN
Orestes Alvarez-Jacinto, MD

November 17, 2008
HIP RESURFACING- AN ALTERNATIVE TO TOTAL HIP REPLACEMENT
Daniel Seybold, MD

November 24, 2008
NEW RADIATION THERAPY SHORTENS BREAST CANCER TREATMENT
Darryl Barton, MD

December 1, 2008
GASTRIC BAND SURGERY
Steve Weiland, MD